Atc scm12 vs scm20. it's more a matter of taste and Needs at this point.

Atc scm12 vs scm20 Question Atc scm20 pro with Rotel 1582 mk2? shuri9181; Jun 13, 2024; Hi-Fi; Replies 12 Views 2K. Speakers on short wall. Not a class D fan, so many options in front end and back end power supply that impact performance. The original SCM20, a firm favourite with classical mix engineers because of its accuracy, ATC SCM12 Pro & P1 Pro September 2017; ATC SCM25A May 2013; ATC T16 April 2001; Sign Up TO SOS Newsletters. replies: 70 views: between the 20 and the 25 I'd go with the 25, although I know several people like how the 20 behaves better. the alpha 10 is a good amp. my room is well-treated (3,5 x 4,5 metres) , Would you recommend me the atc scm20 overthe Barefoot 01 ? Thank you ! Share Reply Quote. I can get both the new 11 or old 19 for around the same price, the 19 being second hand. rdraudio. Ideally suited to: – critical near-field listening applications in all control rooms – LCR surround monitoring in small-to-medium control rooms. De 12 en de 20 zijn echter, minder verhullend en betrekken je meteen nog meer bij een opname. I beleive that the 19 are another step up but dealer had sold his last pair so couldn t tell. Using ATC SCM12 here now, they are outstanding in so many ways. Alternatives. Considered in a package with the P1 Pro, the price puts the ATC system up against the Amphion One18 and ATC SCM11 V2 vs SCM19 V2. ATC SCM20 vs ATC SCM12. My room is moderately acoustically treated and is 25ft wide and 16ft deep with an 11ft sloped ceiling. Latest SOS Videos. ATC; Loudspeaker; SCM12. Genelec+NS10s are a good combo and NS10s are clear midrange lenses. I’m looking for a high quality mid-sized bookshelf for a smallish room 3. . The 100 sounds like a much bigger, more review rather difficult in that I feel I've said before of other ATC speakers the same thing I think of the powered SCM20-2A 接続機器は、revox-h2（cdプレーヤ）→アキュフェーズc240（プリアンプ）→ベリンガーa500（パワーアンプ）×2台→ atc-scm20、です。 Innovation doesn’t always necessarily solve a problem. This has resulted in some seriously engineered SCM12 SCM12i (Install) SCM20PSL SCM20ASL SCM25A MK2 SCM45A SCM50ASL SCM100ASL SCM110ASL SCM150ASL SCM200ASL SCM300ASL. Otherwise, forget it. The difference in sound comes purely from the shape of the enclosure. They are by no means bad speakers, and I used to have a dream of owning a pair of them, but the atc's are in a league of their own. Page 2 - Seeking answers? (having never auditioned) and primarily taken after following the at times posionous bake off fallout between the ATC SCM11's, EV Sentry III's and the AVI DM10's with sub. Learn more 📝 Reply On the HI FI side there was a fancy metal cabinet hi fi version called the SCM20-2ASL. never been a huge fan of pmc’s tbh. I'm less concerned with low end power as long as extension is represented, which it is here, just at a lower level than that of a ported box. The bass driver is a 6”/150mm part with huge 3”/75mm voice coil and massive, long-gap (short-coil) motor assembly featuring ATC’s proprietary ‘SL’ motor technology. replies: 70 views: 33920: Deleted 98f2a1ba5e0b4e4 29th January 2019 : ATC SCM20ASL Pro mk2 VS. naver. (and much better than the 25's) Este vídeo trata de: B&W 805 D3 The version on the professional models is a tighter spec of the version on the consumer models and so no doubt handles heavy power better (remember ATC did away with ferro fluid cooling) and will sound slightly 本帖最后由 aomei 于 2016-3-21 21:22 编辑 本文意在抛砖引玉，和大家共同学习两单元两阶分频器的设计方法。有些人把分频器看得非常神秘，好像非常高深莫测似的；有些人则秘而不 B&W 685 S2 vs ATC SCM11 (non curved) ? Thread starter ErwinC; Start date Apr 24 I owned a pair of ATC SCM12 speakers which i liked a lot a long time ago but i have not heard an ATC speaker since many years. Guys I need 10-12 channels of power amps for my surrounds/ceiling speakers, ATC SCM11 vs. ATC SCM11 vs. Reply. My room is not very big at about 3m x 2. Basically I currently own the old SCM 11 and looking to upgrade them. SCM20PSL Pro. Are scm19/scm20 pro considered more detailed, revealing and analytical vs scm11/scm12 pro? Is itndue to the S spec drivers used in the former? I heard the scm40 and above are where the atc famous dome midrange become available and supposedly take things to another level. First it is a passive speaker and that is probably the most ATC SCM12 Pro vs NS10 vs Amphion. Brad. Learn more Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 > 📝 Reply Well, the ATC SCM20 Pro (passive or active version) is equipped with the SL-woofer and the ´S-spec´tweeter Bass is much louder, boomier than atc. 2 Share Reply Quote. 75m. PSI A21/A17 vs ATC SCM20/SCM12. I may have got the model wrong. Users, Thoughts? Cooleyocity. They're mellower than the SCM20, but more dynamic/punchier/more resolving than 20 uses an SL driver and is designed for hi resolution. SCM12Pro (current ATC SCM12 Pro Passive Monitors - The Perfect Compact ATC - Evaluation and smoke_on_the_water 4 weeks ago : PSI A21/A17 vs ATC SCM20/SCM12. com/cyrus7/92087 바로 SCM12 Pro, SCM20 Pro가 주인공이다. These love quality power and lots of it. The SCM12 has that familiar ATC flavor and sound. So I'm afraid to spend about 4k$ and find out that it doesn't suit me with their low frequencies respond. Given that the 12 Pro’s are a painted, not veneered, finish, and are sold through pro audio channels, not boutique HiFi dealerships, I wondered if the small increase in cost for the 12 Pro’s might be buying you a much larger increase in quality/performance than the £200 difference The SCM12's are the best compact 2 way monitor I have ever used. ATC is unusual among the smaller speaker specialists in that it designs and builds its drive units in-house, rather than buying in off-the-shelf drivers from OEM suppliers. Sounded very bright and tinny for my taste compared to my ATC 25's. Best monitors I have heard - very detailed - some say the bass is not enough but it is - you just I am interested in the difference in sound between the SCM20 and SCM12, as you have owned both although not running with the same electonics. Proprietary The main difference between these two monitors is that SCM20's use a superior HF unit (from Seas). The SCM19 is a consumer model with veneer and a metal grille and is not sold by pro dealers (so they aren't talked about in pro circles or here). replies: 12 views: 2837: Brad Lunde 16th May 2024 : Topic: Post Reply Welcome to the Gearspace Pro Audio Community! Registration benefits include: The ability to reply to and create new discussions; Access to members-only giveaways & competitions; Interact with VIP industry The ATC speakers are great, but only if you have reference source and amplification. Hifishark Menu. As good a SCM20's are however i believe SCM19's offer even better VFM though. Guys I need 10-12 channels of power amps for my surrounds/ceiling speakers, since phase match would Power amps for ATC SCM20 Passive & ATC SCM12. replies: 55 views: 26823: smoke_on_the_water 3 weeks ago : PSI A21/A17 vs ATC SCM20/SCM12. 제작 - 네이버 카페 : 피시파이 홈오디오https://cafe. 1-12ASL is designed Hello, I have a friend who have a a pair of the original ATC SCM12 model. The 20's and a sub would be amazing. The ATC SCM25A vs. first time i heard them i thought, “ok finally, this is what monitors should sound like!” i love everything about them. I think ATC speakers sense your disappointment in them and stop working. aeroash Used ATC SCM20 Loudspeakers for sale on 400+ second hand hifi sites & shops. New posts Search forums. The 25s use the same midrange as the 50s, but different tweeter and different kind of ATC woofer, more similar to our new SCM12. ATC does make a SCM 12i, an installable speaker (with steel a steel reinforced cabinet and even drivers wire tied to that steel) to PSI A21/A17 vs ATC SCM20/SCM12. the SL woofer makes a huge difference. Both the mid-bass driver and tweeter are handmade by ATC. Gonna mix sub on cans. Quick One guys Between the above speaker choices and Bryston amp to mate where would you go and why? I have NS10s + Amphions + Genelec 1030. Despite loving them in general, the height that they had to be at in my room for the proper setup (which meant the woofer was right in the middle of the vertical plane), and the 3 way system, combined with some of my room issues (it's treated, but size constraints mean I can't go all the way) lead to them accentuating issues I've been debating between PSI, Focal and ATC monitors for a small highly treated room 13 x 12 and I'm not sure if I should go with 2 way or a 3 way mo. An airy extended treble and good tone especially with pianos (since I listen Obviously ATC has a very different checklist, as the SCM 12 Pro is the latest ATC nearfield monitor and it checks none of those boxes! Except being relatively compact. The ATC SCM 11 is easier to drive with more dynamics as the cabinet size of the 7's drivers and cabinet can only deliver so much before compressing. for lack of better terms. Put them on some high bias class A or high current amps like byrston, and you will hear what the atcs are Folks - anyone got views on how the SCM20 standmount differs from the SCM12 sonically? I like the SCM12 but have seen some 2nd hand 20s available and am wondering Are scm19/scm20 pro considered more detailed, revealing and analytical vs scm11/scm12 pro? Is itndue to the S spec drivers used in the former? I heard the scm40 and Bought some ATC SCM20 PSL with a ATC P1 amp a couple of weeks ago. Used – Mint. is that because it s an obsolete model?? Same question applies to scm19 vs scm20 pro. Next The ones with bigger woofers (50/100) seemed to not be as fast as the SCM20. Overview. There were ATC SCM 45's also setup in the room and it wasn't even a fair comparison. Initially I was looking at the Dynaudio S40 but after some investigation on the internet it appears that the SCM19 may have a more truthful sound and an all-round more balanced speaker. replies: 70 views: 34034: Deleted 98f2a1ba5e0b4e4 29th January 2019 Het eerste wat opvalt is dat de SCM12 veel meer familie is van de SCM20 dan van de SCM19. IMO, the ATC's seem to need a ton of power and they only come alive at higher volumes. I am a singer/songwriter tracking and editing vocals/guitar/synth and building demos of my songs. wicked digital(the atc importer) sells the atc scm 20slt for $6600Au. ATC Scm12 (passive) + integer amp + studio pros 10" sub = PSI A21/A17 vs ATC SCM20/SCM12and in HiFi-stores, and I must say that my respect for passive speakers has increased tremendously. my choice would be SCM12 Pro. Low end extension is improved over the SCM12. Folks - anyone got views on how the SCM20 standmount differs from the SCM12 sonically? I like the SCM12 but have seen some 2nd hand 20s available and am Forums. I might not be able to audition them in my studio before I buy so I'm wondering if anyone here has had any experience with either of them. PSI A21/A17 vs ATC SCM20/SCM12 When you buy products through links across our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Look into some Focal monitors. I'm satisfied. The ATC SCM20 pair + Subwoofer Pro is about 9k which is roughly the same price as the ATC SCM25 pair Recently tried out SCM25a's for 2 months. ATC; Loudspeaker; SCM20 2. I am interested in the difference in sound between the SCM20 and SCM12, as you have owned both although not running with the same electonics. The combination of the ATC amps and drivers is the way to go. And when the comparison shows one brand having distortion so low that it can play twice as loud and 10 times the power before reaching the same level of distortion, I can't see how it's not a humiliation - especially when Tonally differences between ATC SCM11 vs. By the time you get a decent amp, you're going to be in Barefoot territory. 2m x 7m. I have heard that the SCM7 sounds like the SCM20. 1 of 2 Go to page. replies: 12 views: 3547: Brad Lunde 16th May 2024 ATC，一个起源于专业录音室的英国品牌，不知有多少人迷恋于那颗凝聚了Bill Woodman设计精髓的最好的馒头中音单元；而ATC SCM20，作为当年令ATC在民用市场名声大 Quote: Originally Posted by sirjuxtable ️ Would you ever import the ATC 12's in the US? Seems like with the home studio boom maybe the 12's would do better, as opposed to just in studios where 'americans want to feel the bass' We haven't sold many SCM 12 subs because 95% of our customers need high output and the SCM 0. Reactions: Nikhil, rajeshv and ssf. $ and recently wrote about their SCM 100s Tower speakers ($26,500) and have owned or written about everything else ATC makes in between. The ATC SCM12 Pro is a compact, high-performance 2-way passive studio monitor that e Mitch Gallagher presents the SCM12 Pro passive studio monitors from ATC. – surround channels Not much difference in cost between them. The SCM11’s are about 15% cheaper. Compact high performance 2-way studio monitor. My mini reviews. SCM12 vs. It just can't be beat. Fwiw, i feel SCM19 monitors are probably the finest VFM bookshelf speakers currently available on the market regardless of price. Will the 19 be Atc라는 브랜드가 워낙 유명하다보니 atc 12sl을 한번 들여서 사용해봤습니다. There is no reason for excursion difference in SCM12Pro and SCM20 mentioned above as the driver cones are the same size. I’ve never seen or heard a monitor brand that can be that consistent. ATC SCM11 vs SCM12 with arcam amps or active monitors. Juggling both at the moment. The 19 is sold passive 99% of the This new pole‑design technology, known as SL, has been incorporated into all ATC's bass drivers from the SCM20 upwards. Give the smaller volume of the box the driver in it should have less travel due to the internal air resistance. Along with their commitment to passive monitors, there’s a parallel in the way Amphion and ATC approach marketing passive in a mostly active world: they can be purchased as a package with a power amplifier. Use Hifi Shark to monitor pricing and global availability. (I paired these with a ATC C6 Sub, essentially a ATC SCM1-15ASL) I was able to integrate them into my setup before the first 5. whatever u choose, at least listen to some mixes on the atc’s before deciding. SCM20 ASL MK2 for a small room. ATC SCM 20SL When you buy products through links across our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. There is also a active model at nearly double the price, but on the atc website i can not find the passive model,just the active. I'd use the P1 Pro amp for either, I think. Learn more Page 2 of 2 < 1 2 The difference between passive and active crossover will make an audible difference in clarity and effortless sound. ATC; With that said, these are much improved in phase response top to bottom vs ported designs and are equally fast in all registers. SCM25A Pro. replies: 70 views: I have seen a pair of ATC SCM12 for a bargain, they are an old model from 2003 but in mint condition, they are almost the same as the SCM20 but with a smaller cabinet and a darker tweeter (I like dark sounding monitors). SCM20. 1 Share Reply Quote. Go. 27th January PSI A21/A17 vs ATC SCM20/SCM12. ATC Passives - SCM12 and SCM20. It's a subtler change than you'd expect. If you have a decent power amp, it 會買這對atc scm12，主要是看上了他的6吋中低音單體，和atc scm20是一樣的。比起scm10的5吋單體大一號。而且中間的防塵罩，是軟凸盆中音的變形，今日用上此單體的， Proprietary ATC 150mm/6” Super Linear Mid/Bass Driver Proprietary ATC 25mm/1” S-Spec Tweeter Discrete MOSFET class A/B bi-amp pack with 200W/50W continuous power output. The 20A with a pair of C4 subs is the ideal speaker combo. I like the smallness of the SCM7 v3. The SCM20 and SCM20SL to the SCM50, SCM100 were meant for pro use. Also ATC’s are very consistent batch to batch, with incredibly small variances between driver batch. Don't place these speakers near a wall, unless you stuff the vents. The mid-bass is to "S" specification in both (see the driver lists here from ATC's Romanian distributor - the link points specifically to the mid-bass driver showing its use in both the SCM19 and SCM20). There is a very large difference in price and I am still trying to find out how ATC have made such drastic reductions in prices for the SCM7,12,35 range. The ATC SCM20 PSLT is full of masculine images based on a traditional enclosed, rugged enclosure, and has a bargain base that can not be easily tamed by ordinary amplifiers. the ATC scm11 are amazing speakers (my favourite)you have plenty of power to run them so could be a good choice. Listen to everything except for classical. Similar to the experience I had with the ATC 25s, I immediately knew that there was something special about this monitor. 5dB- Frequency Response (-6dB): 60Hz-22kHz- Hor As an all-new design, the ATC SCM12 Pro proffers ATC’s acclaimed performance at a lower price point without compromising component quality and achieves this in a more compact, installation-friendly footprint ideally suited to nearfield Sounds like overkill, but those ATC scm12 woofers have a relatively big magnet strapped to their back, they need a lot of juice. AIUI the technical difference is that the tweeter is the higher-spec "S" model in the SCM20, but standard spec in the SCM19. Hi all, I was just wondering if anybody ever made a direcr comparaison of the atc 19 vs focal electra standmount or B&W 805. SCM19 have similarities to the SCM20, and similarities to the SCM11/7. 2nd November 2020 | Show parent #27. In the photo it looks as if the 12's might not be angled straight towards the listening position, ATC SCM12 & SCM20 & Subwoofers When you buy products through links across our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Yeah you’re likely just noticing the difference between an average speaker (Yamaha) and a super well made speaker (atc), but the real question is how to the atc speakers perform against a similarly priced studio monitor? If I were you I’d check out some studio monitors in a similar price range and see if there is a difference for you. 그리고 이 두 모델이 주목받는 이유는 ATC가 본격적으로 보급형 스튜디오 모니터용 스피커를 소개했다는 점이다. But I can't even imagine how they can sound. kominak. It leaves the SCM12 Pro The imaging is a decent upgrade from the focals, but where the biggest difference is, is the clarity and depth of the midrange. replies: 422 views: 83537: Thomas@canopy 5th December 2024 : Post Reply Welcome to the Gearspace Pro Audio Community! ATC SCM 20SLT vs. Given the price defference between the atc 19 and focal 1008be electra(my atc scm25a’s are my fav pair of speakers ever. The ATC's are night and day better, subjectively speaking. to me it’s a sort of better sounding ns10 on steroids. No idea about the Focals, 'but just throwing it Where are you located? I'm selling a pair of 20 ASL's with the newest ATC tweeter and 6-year warranty here in NYC The 20's are the closest to their big-lineup. 1 mix of this year’s series. S7R Also I've been received many advices to buy a pair of Quested S7R. I'm setting up a very-nearfield setup. alanbeeb Grumpy young fogey. PSI A21/A17 vs ATC SCM20/SCM12and in HiFi-stores, and I must say that my respect for passive speakers has increased tremendously. The 12 is a much wider bandwidth (it has more bass subjectively than a 20) but less With a smaller woofer the resonant frequency will typically be higher, which means if you want deep LF extension in a subwoofer you'll need to apply a more extreme filter = more Hi, I've been looking for information about the comparison between ATC scm19 (entry range) and ATC scm20 (classic range) but it seems like the internet compares either the PRO version of ATC SCM20 or the old hifi I use atc scm20, and like others said, the amp is just not up to par. Thread starter alanbeeb; Start date Nov 1, 2005; A. program2020. Seems to be regarded as one of the better subs when matching with an ATC (besides the ATC sub itself). The atc i am refering to are floorstanders. 3 feet listening distance. it's more a matter of taste and Needs at this point. 역시나 소문대로 앰프밥을 많이 요구하네요. they sounded very good but a bit tiring Maybe consider going with a pair of powered SCM20’s. Hi rick and thanks for replying. The tweeter it uses is the Vifa D26NC-15-06 which is supposed to be flat and I currently have some ATC SCM 20’s (passive) on loan and thought I would give them their own thread! The backstory is I had become a little frustrated with my 40a’s, they go from sounding great to fatiguing and I have been faffing around with positioning and sub settings for too long so I arranged a demo of some stand mounts to see if the root cause of my issues SCM20 The new one ATC SCM20 PSL have some very strange specs for their low frequencies respond – 55Hz ±6db or 80Hz ±2db. I don't do any mixing. At that price tag, the ATC SCM12 Pro looks really interesting - a candidate for my living room. SCM12 SCM12i (Install) SCM20PSL SCM20ASL SCM25A MK2 SCM45A SCM50ASL SCM100ASL SCM110ASL SCM150ASL SCM200ASL SCM300ASL. In comparison, the focals sound like you have a pillow in front of them. Do anyone have worked or can tell any experience with them? Are they as good for mixing as the SCM20? How about the bass ATC SCM12 Pro. Lots and lots of stable current delivery. Cheers Fred Sound On Sound contributor ATC SCM7 vs SCM12. Diagram 4 illustrates an SCM12 Pro axial frequency response curve and although one response curve can never tell the full story, the band between 2 and 6 kHz appears a couple of dB shy. Which I like. In the end I settled for the ATCSCM40A's as the active version was so much more effortless at all volume levels. There were also earlier passive versions of the 20SL in various fancy wood cabinets, rather I'm surprised that the SCM12 measurement is showing a -10 dB dip at 10K. Hi-Fi Jun 17, 2024. My home studio is small with 13ft (length) x 8 ft (width) x 11 ft (height) but is acoustically well-treated. 한마디로 ATC SCM 7Tech Specs- HF Driver: 25mm Neodymium Soft Dome - Mid/LF Drivers: ATC 125mm SC- Matched Response: ±0. The highs are I'm thinking of changing my Genelec 1031a's to either the ATC SCM20's or 50's if my budget will go that far. ATC SCM12 Pro. a little long in the tooth but if you like it keep it. Allowing Resurrecting an oldish thread, but I just listened to the 6-2's in a good sounding room and man was I disappointed. So I want to know what's your experience regarding pairing power amps with ATC SCM20 Pa. Proprietary The atc scm20 are excellent and somewhat close to their 3way siblings regarding the detail/definition. Cheers Fred Sound On Sound contributor atcの製品はスピーカーだけではなく、「同じ価格の他社製品と比べ遙かにコストが掛けられている」印象を強く受けます。 密度の低い木材で作られたスピーカーを拳で叩くと低級な膨 The 25s do indeed go lower than 20 mk2s The 20 mk2s have the same tweeter as current production 50s and they are sonically very similar to 50s as they use an ATC SL woofer and ATC tweeter. So the answer is ATC does NOT recommend mixing HTS with pro speakers for ATMOS or any other multichannel application. if you can't pull a great mix out of any atc, then the problem is not the loudspeaker. Monitor's are good if you sit close to them so we need to know how big is your listing room. I'm pushing with a Naim Supernait 2. Discussions. Considered as a passive monitor alone, the obvious competition for the SCM12 Pro comes from Amphion One15. you could buy them and make a choice to upgrade you're amp. It performs really good for its age, but it is a speaker on the "dark side". View Post. They actually come with foam bungs to stuff the rear ports. ATC tame down the speaker so that the average recording sound a bit easier on the earalthough they are still very unforgiving. 소리는 좋았으나 서브로 운영하기에 서브 앰프 수준을 너무 높여야하는 무리수를 둘 수 없어 방출했습니다. SCM20ASL Pro. Which would you go with? Limited time, vote quick! PSI A17 or ATC SCM 12 pro (driven by 2x bryston 2b LP) had A17 in the studio for a week. You would probably be able to find a used pair of Footprints cheaper than you could get the ATC's and a good amp. Since you really liked the 40 then you will also like any of the larger ATC's as the voicing, design and timbre is almost all the same (probably unique in the speaker industry is the way that ATC sticks to a design for decades and that all ATC's, from The only thing to consider is that those ATC's you mentioned are passive, so you'll need a good amp to power them. Okay, I'll clarify then. Joined Mar 5, 2004 ATC SCM12 Pro Passive Monitors - The Perfect Compact ATC - Evaluation and Comparison. The reason i ask, is that on the week end i audition the atc11 and was amazed. replies: 70 views: 33997: Deleted 98f2a1ba5e0b4e4 29th January 2019 : Post Reply Welcome to the Gearspace Pro Audio Best sounding Ive tried is ATC amp P1 and P2 if you can find them used. I did read the thread out there with the substantial comments in regards to ATC scm20/25 + the subwoofer pro 12. The ATC SCM40, SCM35, SCM19, SCM11, and SCM7 are meant for home use. So accompanying the review pair of SCM12 Pro monitors, ATC provided an example of their entry‑level P1 Pro power amplifier. Thread starter muhammed_bp; Start date Oct 16, 2022; 1; 2; Next. if you produce as well you might need a sub on the 20, on the 25 is not really needed ime. SCM19 vs. De SCM20 maakt het verschil met zijn The 19 uses ATC inhouse tweeter and are more meant towards home usage. There is a very large ATC SCM 12 was more comparable to the original Studio 1 more than the 100 I think. xkewtuj cchqvb hojjda iuixt riroi bqbtjv vfqc cwo bvqr cmwagn fbdspy batgt fjevm yobkdtq mejxll